Thursday, March 26, 2009

No Applause Please

One thing I'm getting really tired of hearing is the constant applause of people in the United States whenever someone they agree with speaks, or whenever someone says something patriotic. Maybe I'm just watching the wrong kind of television, but it's starting to get really annoying.

My main example is the Daily Show with Jon Stewart. At the beginning of every show, and before and after commercial breaks, the crowd cheers. Once upon a time, people cheered with "Rah" or "Hooray". Also hurrah, huzzah. Today, people almost universally as far as I have heard, cheer with "Woo!" If the men are cheering, it's in falsetto. And every once in a while in the audience of a show like the Daily Show, there's one person who just screams or shrieks above the rest:

"aaaaaaaaaaa!" (deep breath) "breeyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!"

Sometimes it sounds like the people in the audience are riding a roller coaster. Other times it sounds to me like the screams of the damned in hell. I get what the intent is, though, and that is that such a show is supposed to imitate a rock concert, in which the audience is intentionally whipped into a frenzy of emotion, and that's what people go to a rock concert to experience. But it's the screams of the damned that get to me, and I hope that people would start to imagine the tortured damned every time they hear a crowd screaming, and realize how ridiculous this is.

I've been emotional too, so I don't blame people for getting caught up in it. And when it's in a studio/arena setting, there's something thrilling about being in a mob, and all the time knowing that the environment is quite safe. What I don't really understand is why the content of the show should elicit such a response. Basically the audience of a rock concert or a television show are people with houses, families, and jobs, or at least they go to school. A rock concert becomes a mini-riot, the way these people are shrieking and carrying on, and they have no real reason to do it. The issues discussed on the Daily Show are not really worth freaking out so much about, and even if you do freak out in the audience, what are you really doing about the issue? Nothing. If anything, you're blowing off steam about real issues, and you leave that night with a feeling of accomplishment and catharsis. It is clearly and certainly artificial, but the psychological effect is that you feel as if you've done your part. And so you are less compelled to perform other acts in order to fix the things that you screamed about last night.

Of course, that is what the Daily Show is. It's part comedy, part rock concert, and just designed to make you feel good about yourself, so that you watch the advertisements and keep coming back for more. The issues discussed in the show are just designed to make you feel morally superior for watching this kind of show instead of something less edgy, whether it's news or entertainment.

But the problem is not just limited to the Daily Show, as I often see this kind of behavior in college or university settings, like when a school invites a celebrity pseudo-intellectual to speak or debate. Here the crowd is used to being entertained by rock stars, and then they're placed into this format where there's a serious debate going on. They act strangely, and they can either turn on the speaker or misconstrue his words in a strange, populist way.

In some ways, I'd prefer a crowd that says "Boo!" to a crowd that cheers. But the problem with that kind of crowd is that it contains no individuals. I guess what I want from a crowd is confusion. I want some people cheering, some people booing, and the majority thoughtfully contemplating. I guess that makes for a pretty boring performance.

It's such a strange phenomenon when someone goes against a crowd, so you hardly ever have a divided crowd that can simultaneously boo and cheer. When Lincoln said "a house divided against itself cannot stand," I imagine him saying it in the literal sense, in the sense of a theater house. I suppose there's an intentional irony in my using it in this sense, since Lincoln was killed in a theater.

A single heckler can disrupt the entire room; even if the whole room disagrees with him, chaos erupts, because other people might try to shout down the heckler. The entertainer has lots of tricks to drown out hecklers though, especially in a musical setting.

Christian children?

Richard Dawkins argues that children ought not to be labeled with their parents' faith until they are old enough to decide for themselves whether they want to be a part of that faith. Dawkins objects to a child, for example, being called a

Muslim boy
Muslim girl
Christian boy
Christian girl
Jewish boy
Jewish girl
Catholic boy
Catholic girl
Anglican boy
Anglican girl
Protestant boy
Protestant girl

It's fair enough, I'd say, when it comes to issues of belief. How can you tell a child, "because you are born into this family, you must believe that a man can come back from the dead." A reasonable person wouldn't say such a thing, but I'd have to say I don't necessarily object to it. I can see Dawkins' point here though. We are an enlightened society, and we privilege reason, empiricism, logic, and science. So it doesn't matter what our parents tell us in the course of the stories they read to us out of the Bible. Until they are tested scientifically, it is essentially meaningless to say "I believe this" or "I don't believe that."

So what we're left with, is children who say they believe something because it's a part of their identity, not because they have examined it and found it to be true or false.

It reminds me of the debate teams we had in school. Here's how my grade 11 English teacher handled the topic (in a British Columbia state secondary school). We would be given a controversial topic to debate; in one case it was abortion. Before the teacher split the class into two groups, he would ask for the class to put up their hands if they thought abortion was wrong.

"Put up your hand if you think abortion is wrong, and leave your hand up for a minute," he said. I don't know how it worked out so well, but just about exactly half the class was pro-life, and half the class was pro-choice. (30 kids in the class, 15 pro-life and 15 pro-choice or undecided.) My teacher then pointed to each student in turn, while the pro-lifers had their hands raised, and placed them into team 1 or team 2. He didn't say which team would be debating which side, but it became clear at the end of this exercise that most of the pro-lifers were in one group, while the other group was mostly pro-choicers. There was evidently some cross-over, which I assume was also deliberate. I think maybe you can see where I'm going with this, so you won't be surprised to learn that the teacher then assigned a side of the debate to each team. The pro-lifers were assigned the side of the debate that argued in favor of a mother's right to choose. The pro-choicers were assigned to argue that human life begins at conception and thus has rights that ought to be protected. As far as I know, no student protested. We all performed our assignments according to our academic proficiency or lack thereof. None of the students took the opportunity to parody the other side; everyone took the assignment seriously.

Now, we were probably old enough by that time to be considered adults, and those of us who were Christians could probably call ourselves Christians and not be objectionable to Richard Dawkins. But what this illustrates is the difference between being able to hold a belief and being able to evaluate it from an objective point of reference.

That covers the issue of belief, I think. By analogy, I'd say that calling a child a Christian child is the equivalent of putting them on the Christian side of the debate team before they have learned all the facts. Just like my teacher put half the class on the pro-choice side even though they might not have been informed of all the facts surrounding the issue, and they would have to do some reading in order to perform their debating duties. People can change their mind when they get older, and children can decide that they don't like the label they've been given, and change it.

It's not always the easiest thing for a person to do, to change their label and deny some of the things their parents believe, but it's pretty much always been a part of growing up, and even if it doesn't happen with regard to religion, it will at least happen with regard to some other facet of a person's life, which could include sexuality, politics, choice of career, or anything else.

Now, about Richard Dawkins' objection, the other thing I think he fails to mention are the rituals and prohibitions of religion. For one example, what about the Jewish or Muslim student in a school in Europe or America, who doesn't eat pork? How is this supposed to be explained? If children cannot be labeled as Christian or Muslim, then how does one go about explaining to the other students that little Muhammed can't have bacon? Or how does Muhammed explain it? If his parents have been good Muslim parents, then they have explained to him that "you are a Muslim, and we Muslims do not eat pork, and we pray five times a day . . ." etc. Any normal kid is going to say to his classmates "I am a Muslim, so I don't eat ham." And a typical teacher in the modern West is going to understand that Muslims and Jews don't eat pork, and that that's okay. Just don't give that particular kid a ham sandwich.

Problems will naturally arise if either the Muslims or the Christians start using terms like "filthy" to describe the others' eating habits. However, the solution is reasoned explanation and intervention by the teacher, who should explain to the students that "here at school, we don't call each other filthy, dirty, or smelly. Children of different religions have different habits."

Is my picture of the world too rosy? Is this too much to ask of teachers? Or is this too much to ask of teachers to ask of students?

See, I'm not in agreement with Richard Dawkins on his idea that children should not be labeled. I don't believe that it is possible to extinguish labels, and they're going to come up whether you want them to or not. And how hard is it to accept that children of different faiths have different customs and beliefs?

I guess in a way, I am nearer to Dawkins' ideal world. The world he rails against is a world in which even the teachers are complicit in the denigration of minority children. The world Dawkins wants to change is the world in which Christian prayer is mandated every morning, and children pray to Jesus, sing songs about Jesus, and are taught that the Bible is the best and only true book.

I'd actually agree with the latter statement, but I believe that what needs to be taught in schools is that there are other people in the world who have their own scriptures. And maybe the teacher believes that the Bible is the best one, but as a teacher, shklis job is to present the alternatives. After all, you can't know that the Bible is the best and most true book unless you are able to compare it to other examples. And anyways, school is not necessarily in the business of telling you what is best and most true, but of teaching you how to think and communicate using examples drawn from literature, religion, and culture, including both what is thought best and most true, and what is thought poor of, and why does there need to be a value judgment anyways, on a piece meant to illustrate a concept?

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

The Imbalance of Protest

This is a fairly new concept to me, since I'm only on the brink of possibly entering into an administrative or managerial role in some company or other.

Let's look at a protest from both points of view involved.

From the point of view of the authority, the people being disrupted, a protest is an inconvenience, an annoyance. And there are a couple of options you have, none of which involve a special level of effort.

If you are holding an event or a meeting, or some kind of ceremony, one of the things you can do is postpone it to a later date, or move it to a new location, away from the disrupting influence. This is effective because protesters, by definition, have less organizational resources than the "legitimate" authority. You can almost always out-organize protesters.

The other option you have is to remove the protesters, and you can do this in advance or on location. When I say you can remove the protesters, I'm not talking about activeness here, because you can call the police in to do this for you. You don't really have to lift a finger. The only problems that could arise are when your event becomes so large that it attracts such a large group of protesters, that the normal police force of your host community cannot effectively remove the protesters. You have to either hold it in a bigger community, or give the police advance warning, if you know that a protest is possible or likely.

So when a protest happens, you are justifiably annoyed, but it might as well be like calling a ball game on account of rain. It might as well be as if someone forgot some key paperwork, and you have to reconvene at a later date.

Now, to switch things around, we can begin to look at things from the point of view of the protesters. To a protester, a protest is a big deal. To some of them, it means the world, and they are willing to possibly be arrested for their protest. A protester's whole life is put on hold by a protest, and their entire psychology is based in whatever issue they are protesting. To them, nothing else matters. They also tend to perceive their effect as rather large. To them, a victory is to make the rich and powerful, the decision-makers to take notice.

Unfortunately, many protests don't even get that much attention from the powerful. The protesters' only allies are the media. The media are able to make a story out of "we managed to annoy this big corporation/this government."

So for the protester, it is a matter of life and death, but for the authority, it's merely an inconvenience. Often though, the authority is willing to dignify the protest with indignation that it probably doesn't really deserve. I was walking along the sidewalk the other day, and it was flooded with ice-melt. I felt a burning anger in my heart at the inconvenience of having to go a few feet out of my way, and if there had been someone to lash out at, I would have. Authorities tend to do this with minor inconveniences like having to reschedule meetings. This is because it is the bureaucratic mentality that any little change in procedure is unthinkable, unacceptable, and needs to be corrected, loudly. Possibly with police intervention. But these bureaucrats are going to go to sleep in their own homes that night, wake up with the same job the next day, and get pissed off to the same degree that the photocopier still isn't working. They'll deal with it.

The protesters won't necessarily deal. They might wake up in jail. They might lose their jobs. They certainly don't have a corporate juggernaut to keep them rolling along in their fight against the system. They have the media, but the media can only do so much, and (as I've mentioned before) the media cannot be trusted. Not by the protesters, not by the powerful, and not by the consumers. The protesters are the ultimate underdogs in any such contest.

Monday, March 16, 2009

There Are No Accidents in Poetry

There are no accidents in poetry.

I'd say this goes all the way back to the book of Job, whenever that was written. In the book of Job, all kinds of bad things happen to Job, and as far as he knows, there's no reason for them. But it takes the whole book for him to realize this. Each of the speeches of his friends seems to posit a reasonable explanation for what has befallen him.

I recently read a poem by a fellow student, and in this poem, what happens is a woman does a strip-tease in a hotel room, throws an article of clothing on top of a lamp, it catches on fire, and it burns the apartment up, including her. An accident, right?

As the title of this post suggests, there are no accidents in poetry. I could equally say that there are no accidents in dreams. There are no accidents in fantasies. There are no accidents in daydreams. There are no accidents in wishing.

That is to say, if something happens in a poem, it is because some part of the poet wished for it to happen. Shall I add murder to the list of crimes of poets? I think I might, especially when there is no poetic justification for the death. (Incidentally, I have been guilty of destroying the entire world in a poem, just for the sake of destruction.)

Tragic loss plays a few key roles in poetry and fiction. Often, it is something for the protagonist and other characters to rail against. "My friend is dead! Why did God/the universe inflict this on me?" Other times it is a lesson for the reader to avoid circumstances. "Oh he knew that if he ate the fruit of the Tree of Certain Death that he would die! And so he has! Alas, but we cannot grieve, for the universe is just! It rewards stupidity with pain, and immorality with vengeance!"

I guess my problem with the poet as murderer is that sometimes the poet sends the wrong message with the death of a character. My friend's poem is an example of this, I think. We are given very few details of the dancer, except a few about what her lifestyle might have been like, the fact that she's in a hotel, the fact that she's willing to do a striptease, and we begin to get the picture that some folks might consider that she's almost deserving of a fate approximating what she got. It was her who threw the camisole on the lamp, after all. She accidentally killed herself.

And yet, there are no accidents in poetry. The lesson in the poem is that the dancer has transgressed against the law of the universe, and the universe has seen fit to extinguish her.

So, if I had the chance, I would re-write the poem, and include enough details to take the blame off the dancer. I would make her more like Job, even though she might still have a lifestyle filled with drugs, sex, and lies. I would be left with a very different portrait of a person, I suppose. But the fact is, I don't believe that anyone deserves to die. The closest I could get would be that those who deliberately commit suicide might deserve it, and yet I can't quite bring myself even to that point.

The problem with my friend's poem is that it is almost comical. The reader is almost brought to laugh at the self-inflicted plight of this pathetic, worthless creature. We're not sorry to see her go. We cheer the flames on. And no, I don't think this idea is coming from within me. I think it is implicit in the work of art whenever a person dies accidentally by their own hand, in a poem or work of fiction.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Poem in Progress

The following is a rough extract from a poem I'm working on as part of a larger project for my creative writing project. I imagine it will look quite different when it is done, and it will be a lot longer. I post it here merely as an example of the kind of work I'm trying to take seriously at the moment, since most of what this blog is is a break from seriousness, and a place to put things that I don't really care about. I'm sort of going against that in this post, but not really, because this poem is by no means complete, nor am I entirely certain whether it will end up in the final compilation. Anyways, might as well give you the poem.

In one dream, we explored the sea,
played in its shallows, scoured its depths
Humbobs, makers of ropes
designed fleets of fortresses
so big that we could cover the edge of the world
just like the entrances of our houseboats.
Young jorns climbed the ropes
up into the sun and down into the abyss
We ate the airy fruit, swallowed the dense bread,
and danced to the scrolls of all-is-oneness.
Six vectors belonged to the kings of us
but scant record of the seventh remains.

Now we are a valley people,
though we still wander, the seventh vector is our anchor.
I don’t know if we ever had hearts
when we were being born in the sea.
And the entrance to the abyss is not known,
even though the Scurbdads strung their guidestrings.
The leading twines are cut, the supporting lines are tangled,
and we don’t know the way to heaven or hell.
We call out in the voices of birds,
and we have learned how the echoes answer:
“Go back. I am a solid wall.”
“Turn around. I’m just the ground.”

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Commas and Poetry

I think commas have been very lucky in today's poetry. It seems that other punctuation has been either abandoned or severely reduced. Yet the comma remains.

The period is often omitted due to its ominous finality. Language with periods is neither nuanced nor particularly intelligent. Language with commas is open to interpretation. Language with commas can hold multiple ideas in the same thought. We don't often speak out loud in periods anymore.

Capitalization has also received a major blow in that it is no longer really quite comfortable to include capital letters in a familiar or politically undersurging poetry. Language with capital letters almost seems authoritarian. Language without them is inviting the reader to decide which words are the most important. The little I is indicative of a non-threatening author. An entire line of little letters is aesthetically more pleasing than a line with the occasional mutant capital.

On the internet a string of all capital letters indicate shouting. By the inverse logic a passage neglecting to capitalize anything could almost be construed as a whisper.

If You Should Stumble Upon This Blog Accidentally

Up until now, I have purposefully not promoted this blog, not to my friends, family, colleagues, or anybody. But I have written it with the belief that eventually they all might see parts of it.

It's like standing in the middle of a prairie where no roads are, and stripping naked, waiting to see if someone comes along.

Anyways, if you do happen to see something that I've written that strikes you, please give a link to your friends. You have my permission. This is not a secret blog.

If you see nothing of value, that's fine too. Just move along, and I wish you the best.